All of the Field Sobriety Tests provide numerous opportunities for officer error in administering the test and in interpreting its results and for your Illinois DUI Defense Lawyer to attack the supposed validity of your "failing" HGN Test results. The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) Test is no exception. It requires the test subject (you) to follow a stimulus with your eye as the officer moves it from side to side. The stimulus on a roadside Field Sobriety Test is usually something like the officer's pocket flashlight.
Illinois DUI Defense Lawyers understand that the concept behind the HGN Test postulates that the presence of a central nervous system depressant like alcohol will affect your eye pupil size, your ability to smoothly track objects like the stimulus with your eye, and your ability to control the muscles that control your eye's movements. Through this HGN Field Sobriety Test, the officer tries to evaluate your pupil size, tracking, smooth pursuit, and “distinct” nystagmus at "maximum deviation” to determine whether your driving is impaired by alcohol. This is no simple or straightforward task.
The test procedures follow this pattern:
The crucial issue in a Field Sobriety Test is whether that test was administered and interpreted while precisely following the NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration) guidelines for the test. One research study concluded that officers administer Field Sobriety Tests incorrectly more than 90% of the time.
The NHTSA training manual warns that the standardized Field Sobriety Tests like the HGN Test are not flexible. At all. In order to have any value at all as evidence, Illinois DUI Defense Lawyers insist that Field Sobriety Tests be administered each time exactly as prescribed by the NHTSA. Officers must not deviate from the NHTSA instructions in any way. The NHTSA manual cautions that the HGN Field Sobriety Test results could only to be considered valid indicators of your blood alcohol concentration (BAC) level when:
If even one of the standardized test elements is changed or improperly administered or interpreted, the validity of the test as a reliable indicator of your BAC level is ruined.
The validity of any results obtained in this phase is totally dependent on the officer’s ability to administer the test perfectly and without even the smallest deviation from NHTSA guidelines. The NHTSA requires that the stimulus be moved at a speed that takes at least 2 seconds from the center position to the point of maximum deviation. Under uncontrolled roadside field conditions, the officer must make a best guess regarding speed and timing.He must simultaneously attempt to evaluate the suspect’s performance.
The prosecution must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt in order for you to be convicted on a DUI Charge. Even where your arresting officer claims that you "failed" the HGN Test, your Chicago DUI Attorney could raise several issues that could create reasonable doubt about your intoxication:
As mentioned previously, the HGN Test must be given correctly in order to have any value as evidence. Under the NHTSA guidelines,at least 25 different steps must be performed to properly conduct the HGN Test.These procedures must be followed with precision and failure to do so renders the results inaccurate and unreliable.
There are several common mistakes that officers tend to make in the field in administration of the roadside HGN Field Sobriety Test that your Chicago DUI Attorney could attack on cross-examination at your trial:
There are eye disorders, neural disorders, and other conditions that can cause nystagmus and affect your HGN Test results. They can cause you to "fail" an HGN Test even when you haven't had a single drink. Among the conditions that can affect your HGN Test results are:
Your Chicago DUI Attorney could demonstrate through careful questioning on cross-examination at your trial that the arresting officer was no expert in the science behind the HGN Test. Your Chicago DUI Attorney could ask whether the officer had special training to detect neural or eye disorders,whether he asked you if you have any neural or eye disorders, and whether he consulted your medical records to determine if you had any neural or eye disorders.
Your Chicago DUI Attorney Could Attack the Arresting Officer's Qualifications to Conduct the HGN Test, which is an Ophthalmologic Examination
The HGN Test is basically an ophthalmologic examination that tests a person's eye movements. Nearsighted and farsighted folks who get regular ophthalmologic exams have no doubt taken the test several times and might be familiar with the essential procedure.
You cover (or in a Field Sobriety Test context close) one eye. You focus your other eye on a little beam of light from the examiner's special testing instrument. This is the "stimulus" and in the case of your arresting officer might have been a pocket flashlight.
As your eye follows the light beam stimulus during the test,your eye will begin to exhibit some nystagmus (involuntary oscillations) as the beam reaches a deviation of 40 degrees or more from the center point. In an intoxicated person or a person affected b y prescription drugs or some other neural and eye conditions, that nystagmus reaction will occur before the 40-degree mark.
But the HGN Test is an ophthalmologic examination that requires some experience and training in order for the tester to be able to determine the cause of the nystagmus and whether it is natural to the test subject or the product of additional influences like alcohol. Your arresting officer is trained to look for signs of intoxication thorough the HGN Test, so that is the factor to which he will attribute your signs of nystagmus. An actual trained ophthalmologist has learned to look for the other potential eye or neural disorders first. The HGN Test is biased when administered by an unqualified individual that is not an ophthalmologist.
Thorough questioning of the arresting officer on cross-examination could make him admit that:
Your Chicago DUI Attorney could create reasonable doubt about the value of your HGN Test results in relation to the DUI Charge by carefully demonstrating that the officer was not really qualified either to administer the HGN ophthalmologic exam or to interpret its results.
During your HGN Test, the officer will attempt to make the highly technical determination of whether you demonstrate "distinct"nystagmus at some point of your eye's maximum deviation from the center resting point of the eye. Nystagmus is the involuntary oscillation of the eye in response to a loss of muscle control. Many other things than alcohol's depressant effect on the central nervous system can cause it. Heat stroke victims often display nystagmus to a high degree.
People with the condition called "lazy eye" often display a highly visible form of nystagmus. But nystagmus to some degree is present naturally in all individuals, especially at the point of the eye's maximum deviation. Maximum deviation is a difficult position for the eye's muscles to hold. And nearsighted and farsighted persons with variable eye muscle tension might be more prone to nystagmus at maximum deviation.
Maximum deviation is the point at which the eye has moved fully to one side and cannot move any farther. The officer must attempt the complex and technical tasks of distinguishing whether your eye's oscillations are “distinct” nystagmus or natural nystagmus and then accurately identifying your eye's point of maximum deviation.
Different individuals naturally have greater or less maximum deviation and peripheral vision. And determining whether your nystagmus is a natural condition or caused by alcohol's depressant effect on the central nervous system presents a real technical challenge.
As your Chicago DUI Attorney realizes, the HGN Test is held by officers to be a scientific and objective test of your level of intoxication. But the HGN Test is deeply flawed for two reasons:
The administration of the test cannot be effectively controlled or standardized when performed under field conditions like a busy roadside at night; and
The results that the HGN Test produces in the field under the administration of an officer not specifically qualified to give ophthalmologic tests are fully subjective products of the varying perceptions and interpretations of various law enforcement officers and their expectations.They expect to see nystagmus caused by alcohol consumption; therefore they willsee it.
Even with an accuracy rate of only around three out of our tests, the HGN Test is regarded as the most accurate Field Sobriety Test.But even when administered accurately by officers, the HGN Test gives only a 77% accuracy rate. That means that out of every 100 HGN Tests given, 23 of them remain inaccurate.
A U.S. DOT (Department of Transportation) report called Improved Sobriety Testing acknowledges the poor accuracy rate by stating that where an HGN Test indicates a driver might be impaired by alcohol, the officer should also administer the other two standardized tests to provide more firm data on which to base a DUI arrest. The other two tests standardized by the NHTSA are the One Leg Stand Test and the Walk and Turn Test.
If an officer arrested you because you "failed"the HGN Test, your Chicago DUI Attorney should question whether the other two standardized tests were also given to you. If not, your Chicago DUI Attorney could point out that the officer failed to abide by the accepted procedure detailed by the U.S. DOT. Without the other two test results, your officer could not, under U.S. DOT guidance, have firm data to support your DUI arrest.Your Chicago DUI Attorney could also reiterate that the HGN test is accurate only about 77% of the time.
Your DUI trial is your one chance to attack the prosecution's case against you and escape conviction on the DUI Charge. To do that, you need the skill, knowledge, and experience of an effective Illinois DUI Defense Lawyer like Michael Schmiege on your side.
Hire aggressive and effective Illinois DUI Defense Lawyer Michael P. Schmiege to take your case to trial and to cross-examine the officer that arrested you. Michael Schmiege's skilled cross-examination of your arresting officer could reveal that he improperly administered and evaluated your HGN Test and that the test results are therefore inaccurate. This tactic could create the reasonable doubt that you need to avoid conviction on the DUI Charge.
Contact Illinois DUI Defense Lawyer Michael Schmiege today for a free case evaluation consultation. Let him help you understand your legal options. Michael P. Schmiege's aggressive advocacy could safeguard your right sand provide your key to freedom after a DUI charge based on an improperly administered HGN Field Sobriety Test. (312) 906-7800
NOT GUILTY – Possession of a Controlled Substance w/ Intent to Deliver
Driving Under the Influence of Alcohol – NOT GUILTY
"I am so appreciative of the help and support that I received from Michael and his team members! They truly helped me figure out my case and I got outstanding results. If anyone can help you get great results, it’s Michael. I had an immigration issue as well and he worked with my immigration lawyer to help find the best solution. He understood that I made a mistake but it didn’t define who I was. I definitely don’t want to go through any of this again but I’m glad that I had the support to get through this."
"Michael Schmiege is an excellent attorney. He is honest, diligent and gets great results. If you find yourself in need of a lawyer, he is great at what he does. Never over-promises, but definitely delivered more than we had hoped for. His team will help you all the way. Answers all your questions promptly and clearly states what to expect. I highly recommend Michael and his team. They CAN and will help!"
"Mr. Schmiege is well respected by the court because he is a very honest man. He was very kind and respectful to me. His fees were reasonable. His office is very easy to find, and his staff is very helpful."